A defendant is on trial for arson. Two weeks before the fire, a friend of the defendant, who has since passed away, told a mutual acquaintance, 'I know the defendant has been stockpiling gasoline in his garage for months. He told me he plans to use it to set his former workplace on fire unless his boss apologizes to him.' The acquaintance wishes to testify to this statement. The prosecution seeks to admit it under the hearsay exception for statements against interest. Should the court allow this statement to be admitted?
No, because the acquaintance's testimony is inadmissible under the hearsay exceptions that apply in this case.
Yes, because the declarant is unavailable, and the statement is against someone's interest.
Yes, because the statement is relevant to the defendant’s intent and therefore admissible.
No, because the statement implicates the defendant rather than the declarant.
The correct answer explains that for a statement to qualify as a statement against interest, the declarant must be unavailable, and the statement must be one that a reasonable person in the declarant’s position would not have made unless they believed it to be true and it was contrary to their own interest at the time. In this case, while the declarant is unavailable due to their passing, the statement implicates the defendant but not the declarant directly, so it does not satisfy the strict criteria for a statement against interest. Additionally, the testimony may not fall under another hearsay exception. The incorrect answers fail to recognize the importance of the self-incriminating aspect of the declarant’s statement in qualifying it under the exception.
Ask Bash
Bash is our AI bot, trained to help you pass your exam. AI Generated Content may display inaccurate information, always double-check anything important.
What does 'hearsay' mean in legal terms?
Open an interactive chat with Bash
What constitutes a 'statement against interest'?
Open an interactive chat with Bash
Why is the availability of the declarant important in hearsay exceptions?